How to Invest an Inheritance or Windfall

With proper management and investing, receiving an inheritance is an opportunity to strengthen your financial plan and improve your progress towards financial independence.

However, this does not usually happen. On average, 1 in every 3 inheritances are spent down in 2 years or less. Here’s how to create a sustainable, successful plan around your inheritance and some pitfalls you may encounter:

Investing an Inheritance

What are Your Goals?

For most, inheritances are treated very differently than their other savings, and that leads to money be wasted or spent differently than they would with other money. So, before you begin spending your inheritance, its important to go back to your goals and see what needs help to fund.

For example, if you have a goal of retiring, than that inheritance money should go towards maximizing long term retirement savings such as an IRA or Roth IRA. Don’t use this new money to buy a new car, a new house, or other items that will not contribute to your retirement goal.

Or, if you had a goal to pay for a child’s or grandchild’s college expenses, than using inheritance money to help start or fund a 529 should be a priority.

After you receive and inheritance, it is important to make sure any money is spent in a productive way that goes towards supporting those goals.

You may find that even after these goals are funded you have money left over. That is the time to consider adding new goals and expenses to your financial plan, not before.

Goal planning is just one part of a comprehensive financial plan that we help create for our clients. Here’s a look at everything that goes into our plans for clients.

Adding Expenses After Receiving an Inheritance

Why do so many inheritances get squandered? The problem is that many of the items frequently purchased with a windfall do not go towards improving net worth. Many of those who receive a windfall quickly imagine driving new cars or buying a new house. Besides just the initial purchase cost, these purchases add additional expenses to your budget such as taxes, upkeep, insurance, utilities, and more.

These ongoing expenses over the course of your life require significant savings to support. Unfortunately, these purchases and their ongoing expenses may instead quickly drain whatever was left of your windfall.

If financial independence or retirement is a priority for you, make sure your windfall is invested in a way to ensure your desired lifestyle is sustainable.

When we talk with clients who have received money from an inheritance, we go through several goal planning exercises to make sure that there is a plan for the money to be invested, and spent, in a sustainable fashion.

Retirement success after investing an inheritance with buying a new home

Taxes Around Inherited Money and Accounts

Depending on the types of accounts and assets you inherit, you may be subject to new rules and taxes you were not familiar with before. Not being familiar with these can lead to larger chunks of inherited money being forced to pay for taxes or penalties rather than going towards your financial goals.

Each account type or asset will have its own rules, but here are a few common ones:

Inherited IRAs

If you inherit an IRA that is not from your spouse, you will be subject to new RMD, or required minimum distribution rules. The rules around calculating RMDs on inherited assets has recently changed, so its important to make sure you understand how the current law is written.

For example, assume you receive a $500,000 inheritance in the form of an inherited IRA. You will have 10 years to withdrawal the money from that account. Not so hard right?

The problem comes when you consider the taxes that you will have to pay from making those withdrawals.

Taxes on a $500k Inheritance – Example

Any money your receive from an inherited IRA is taxed like normal income. So, if you were to withdrawal that entire $500k in a single year, your tax bill will likely be astronomical.

Image from Forbes – “IRS Announces 2021 Tax Brackets”

Consider a $500,000 inheritance for a married couple with $100,000 in regular income located in Iowa.

If they would entirely cash out the $500,000 inherited IRA, they would pay a Federal tax rate as high as 35%, and also Iowa state’s tax rate of 8.53% for a total tax bill of over $210,000!

So, you want to develop a plan to use any inherited money that is in an IRA is a responsible matter. You may want to space out distributions from inherited IRAs to reduce your tax bill. Or, you may want to match large distributions with years that you have a large tax deduction, such as a charitable donation, or deductions from tax loss harvesting.

Note: These rules and tax rates have changed over time and will continue to change. Depending on when you inherited the money, may not apply to you. Be sure to check with a financial advisor to ensure any advice received is relevant to you.

If you have questions about investing your inheritance, you are in the right place. Click here to schedule a free, no obligation 30 minute introductory meeting with us today to see how we can help set you.

Taxable Investment Accounts

These accounts, also known as individual brokerage accounts, usually do not present the same tax issues as inherited IRAs, but there do often cause other tax issues.

First, investments in these accounts produce taxes in 3 different ways; Capital Gains, Dividends, and Interest. Each of these 3 may be taxed at different rates depending on your income.

So, its important to understand where you sit in the Federal tax brackets to know if these assets will create a large tax liability for you.

For example, If you have low income, under $80,000 if married, you may be able to take advantage of a special provision in the tax code to qualify for 0% tax rate for long term capital gains and qualified dividends. Likewise, if you have high income you may be subject to additional taxes on dividends!

Next, consider if the investments in that account that you inherited are appropriate for you. Taxable investment accounts can hold a wide variety of investments, from municipal bonds to high yield junk bonds.

Depending on your situation these may not be appropriate investments for you (and even lead to a high tax bill in some cases!)

Inherited Roth IRAs

Roth IRAs are great in that they don’t result in the heir receiving any additional tax burden.

The “burden” for the heirs falls on knowing when and how to use that inherited money.

Inherited Roth IRAs also have the same RMD, or required minimum distribution rules, that traditional IRAs have. In general it is best to keep investments in these accounts for as long as possible.

Some exceptions may be during years of high spending or high income, when it may be worth using the tax-free Roth money to avoid withdrawals from your other investment accounts.

How To Invest an Inheritance

Once you have your goals established and your tax burden determined, now it is time to invest your inheritance so that you can meet your goals in the future.

It is impossible to suggest how to invest your proceeds through just a blog post. Your investments depend on your risk tolerance, the time horizon of your goals, and the exact types of assets you inherited.

However we can offer general advice that we use in managing all of our client’s assets.

Find Low Cost Investments

All investments have some sort of cost. For ETFs and Mutual Funds, most of these expenses come from a funds “expense ratio”. This is simply the annual fee that fund companies charge for investing your assets.

Over time, these expenses can really add up. Below is an example from an expense ratio calculator that shows the impact of these fees over time:

expense ratios on inherited assets and investments

It is important that you are comfortable finding these low cost types of investments and building a portfolio around them.

Diversified Investments

If you are investing your inheritance, choosing investments that will grow over time is important.

Choosing investments that are broadly diversified is an important step in meeting that need. Diversification means not having “all of your eggs” in a single basket.

For investing, that means having a wide variety of different types of investments. You want large companies, small companies, and international companies. It might also mean adding bonds for safety.

Building a diversified investment portfolio does just this. When we work with clients and develop an asset allocation, it typically includes investments in many different areas:

Asset Allocation for investments

And More…

Besides just finding your initial investments, there are numerous investment account maintenance items that you will now have to do.

We have separate blog posts and webinars that deal with some of these topics:

Tax Loss Harvesting – If you received an inheritance in the form of a taxable investment account, you may have the ability to get tax deductions when the value of those investments go down. This can be incredibly valuable if you take advantage.

Rebalancing – Over time, your investments will become overweight in the assets that have performed well recently. Rebalancing your investment accounts means ensuring that your investments stay diversified over time.

Get Help

For most, receiving an inheritance can be life changing. It can provide stability in your finances, freedom in your work or lifestyle, and comfort.

If you are not confident in your ability to manage that money, seek help. A third of all inheritances are gone in 2 years or less. Don’t fall into the same problems that countless others have that leads to the squandering of their inheritance.

As fiduciary, fee-only advisors we help clients with this every day. From goals to investing to taxes, we will help create a plan for you that ensures your inheritance is used and invested in the best way possible.

We offer free, no-obligation meetings so that you have the chance to ask us questions about your windfall, our investment process, or whatever else is on your mind.

Let's Get Started

You'll get the most value from financial planning if your specific goals and needs match a firm's philosophy and services. Let's learn more about each other.

Ready to Get Started?